Can conscription be morally justified during a time of war?

If one can reasonably argue that conscription at a given level (producing a certain amount of reduced freedom) would prevent more freedom from being lost in the event of defeat, that yes, it is justified.

Is military conscription moral?

To hold a draft in response to a military action that the Congress, as representatives of the American people, did not choose, is immoral. (4) The draft can also be ethical only if it is implemented with the public’s consent.

What is conscription Why was is necessary during the war?

Conscription is the orderly selection of people (usually men) for required military service. It is usually employed when a small standing army must be expanded because of the threat or outbreak of war. Since prehistoric times men have been trained from youth to defend their communities against attack.

Is it a good idea to use conscription?

Mandatory national service would foster unity and bring people from diverse backgrounds together. Compulsory service would save the government money and provide benefits to all citizens. Performing national service would help young people mature and serve as a bridge to adulthood.

See also  How can Science, Religion, Theoretical Philosophy, and Spirituality be compatible / not cause conflict with each other?

What are the arguments against conscription?

Anti-conscriptionists also argued in the name of ‘liberty’ – defending the right of ordinary men to decide for themselves whether to fight and die. They argued that conscription was the ultimate form of state tyranny.

Was conscription used in the Civil War?

During the Civil War, the U.S. Congress passes a conscription act that produces the first wartime draft of U.S. citizens in American history. The act called for registration of all males between the ages of 20 and 45, including aliens with the intention of becoming citizens, by April 1.

What does conscription mean in ww1?

compulsory enrollment for service

conscription, also called draft, compulsory enrollment for service in a country’s armed forces.

What are the pros and cons of conscription?

Top 10 Conscription Pros & Cons – Summary List

Conscription Pros Conscription Cons
Good to discipline young men Accidents
Perseverance may increase Confined freedom
Good preparation for the work world May be an outdated concept
May be good for character development Waste of time

What was the effect of conscription in ww1?

Effects of conscription

2) Act raised the age limit to 51. Conscription was extended until 1920 to enable the army to deal with continuing trouble spots in the Empire and parts of Europe. During the whole of the war conscription had raised some 2.5 million men.

How was conscription different in ww1 and ww2?

In WWI, 400,000 men were drafted, 125,000 showed up to duty, and 25,000 reached stations before the war ended. In WWII, 130,000 men were drafted, and 2,500 reached their assignments before the fighting stopped.

See also  What philosophical views are there on the problem of boredom?

How did conscription work in ww2?

The National Service (Armed Forces) Act imposed conscription on all males aged between 18 and 41 who had to register for service. Those medically unfit were exempted, as were others in key industries and jobs such as baking, farming, medicine, and engineering.

Was conscription good or bad for Canada?

The Conscription Crisis. During First World War, the issue of military service touched the soul of French Canada, sparking violence and bloodshed and ripping open the country’s linguistic divide. When war erupted in 1914, it caused a patriotic fervor in English Canada.

Who was opposed to conscription and why?

All of his English-speaking ministers supported the idea. However, his two French-Canadian ministers were hesitant. They fully understood the negative reactions that French-Canadians would have. The French-Canadian nationalists who opposed conscription viewed it as neither necessary nor successful.

Is conscription still a thing?

United States — De jure – The United States military has been all-volunteer since 1973. But an act of Congress could still reinstate the draft in case of a national emergency. Uruguay — De jure – Conscription currently inactive, but government is authorized to activate conscription in case of national emergency.