Is this general argument against immortality valid?


What did Plato think about immortality?

Eastern religions (for example, Hinduism and Buddhism) and some ancient philosophers (for example, Pythagoras and Plato) believed that immortal souls abandon the body upon death, may exist temporarily in an incorporeal state, and may eventually adhere to a new body at the time of birth (in some traditions, at the time …

What is immortal according to philosophy?

immortality, in philosophy and religion, the indefinite continuation of the mental, spiritual, or physical existence of individual human beings.

Do you find Plato’s arguments for the immortality of the soul convincing?

Plato believes that this knowledge is pre-natal, and so through dialogue argues that if man has a priori knowledge, the soul must exist before the body. This argument however does not prove that the soul exists immortally.

What are the two arguments of Plato for the immortality of the soul?

The Phaedo gives us four different arguments for the immortality of the soul: The Argument from Opposites, the Theory of Recollection, the Argument from Affinity, and the final argument, given as a response to Cebes’ objection. Plato does not seem to place equal weight on all four of these arguments.

See also  How is the individualist position essential for peace and prosperity in a society

What is immortality in the bible?

Overview. Immortality is a state of endless life beyond the power of death, which is obtained following the Resurrection. All mortal souls will eventually become immortal through the power of the Resurrection of Jesus Christ.

Is the immortality of the soul in the Bible?

The modern scholarly consensus holds that the canonical teaching of the Old Testament made no reference to an immortal soul independent of the body. A wide range of scholarly reference works consistently represent this view.

Is immortality possible?

Cryonics holds out the hope that the dead can be revived in the future, following sufficient medical advancements. While, as shown with creatures such as hydra and Planarian worms, it is indeed possible for a creature to be biologically immortal, it is not known if it will be possible for humans in the near-future.

What is one argument for the immortality of the soul given in the Phaedo?

The lecture focuses exclusively on one argument for the immortality of the soul from Plato’s Phaedo, namely, “the argument from simplicity.” Plato suggests that in order for something to be destroyed, it must have parts, that is, it must be possible to “take it apart.” Arguing that the soul is simple, that it does not …

What is Socrates final argument for the immortality of the soul in Phaedo?

The only way for a soul to “perish” would be to die, accepting death. Since a soul cannot accept death, it must withdraw intact at the approach of death. Thus, the soul cannot perish; it is indestructible. Indestructibility entails immortality.

See also  Is it true that there is no "long-run relative frequency" for a theory being true?

What argument is offered for the soul’s immortality quizlet?

What argument is offered for the soul’s immortality? The reason the body dies is because it is not a self-mover; therefore, because that soul is one, and is a source of life and energy, it can be immortal.

What argument is Ofered for the soul’s immortality?

What are the four basic arguments offered up by Plato for the immortality of the soul? 1) Everything comes from its opposite 2) Opposites emerge from each other in a cyclical process 3) Life and death are opposites; If death comes from life, life must come from death.

How does Plato agree with Heraclitus?

Heraclitus had a very strong influence on Plato. Plato interpreted Heraclitus to have believed that the material world undergoes constant change. He also thought Heraclitus was approximately correct in so describing the material world.