Logical error in Augustinian theodicy

What are the weaknesses of Augustine’s theodicy?

Weaknesses of Augustine’s Theodicy ( Moral problems with the theodicy …

  • Logical problem: nothing comes from nothing. …
  • Logical problem 2: The point at which Knowledge arose. …
  • Logical Problem 3: The Omniscience and Omnipotence of God.

What is St Augustine’s theodicy?

Augustine’s soul-deciding theodicy

God foretold that this fall would happen and therefore sent his son, Jesus Christ, so that humanity may be reconciled with God. Augustine’s theodicy bases the origin of evil and suffering on humanity and takes that responsibility away from God.

What are Augustine’s views on the problem of free will?

God created the free will, and the free will to Adam and Eve and later every one, every one has a natural freedom will. Augustine thought that it was a kind of ability to exist in our soul, it is a kind of ability of reason and freedom.

See also  What is intelligence?

What is moral evil Augustine?

structure remains: moral evil is a specific form of corruption, a deprivation of goodness in a specific place—the will. Augustine is one of the first great philosophers of free will. He thinks deeply about the will and its freedom precisely because he wants to understand its corruptibility, the way it can go bad.

What are the strengths of Augustine’s theodicy?


  • Gives an explanation as to why there is natural and moral evil.
  • States that God did not create evil as it is not a ‘thing’, therefore, God is not responsible for it.
  • Allows for humans to be ‘saved’ through Jesus-Shows a benevolent God.

Feb 23, 2016

Why is it called the inconsistent triad?

It is called the Inconsistent Triad because it is comprised of three states of existence (making three corners of a triangle) that supposedly cannot co-exist.

What is the problem of theodicy?

A theodicy is an attempt to justify or defend God in the face of evil by answering the following problem, which in its most basic form involves these assumptions: God is all good and all powerful (and, therefore, all knowing). The universe/creation was made by God and/or exists in a contingent relationship to God.

What is the logical problem of evil?

The logical problem of evil is the appearance of inconsistency between the existence of God and the existence of any evil at all. A defence against the logical problem of evil is an argument that purports to show that this appearance is misleading and in fact there is no such inconsistency.

See also  Are there forms of capital which are not overtly economic?

What are the three Theodicies?

Thomas Aquinas, the 13th-century Dominican theologian, and in the Theodicy (1710), by the German philosopher and mathematician Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz. According to Leibniz, there are three forms of evil in the world: moral, physical, and metaphysical.

How does St Augustine solve the problem of evil?

Augustine proposed that evil could not exist within God, nor be created by God, and is instead a by-product of God’s creativity. He rejected the notion that evil exists in itself, proposing instead that it is a privation of (or falling away from) good, and a corruption of nature.

What does Evodius conclude about evil at the end of the text )?

Evodius knows it is evil because he would not tolerate it if someone tried to commit adultery with his own wife, and anyone who does to another what he does not want done to himself does evil; St.

What is Augustine’s solution to the problem of evil in Book VII?

Similarly, although Augustine now thought of Manichee dualism as “an abomination,” he still had no solution to the problem of evil. He even reached the point of suspecting (after listening to other Catholics) that human free will causes evil, but was left with the question of why humans can choose evil at all.

Why does Augustine finally abandon astrology?

He is finally convinced that astrology is false, after he hears the story of a rich man and a beggar born at exactly the same moment, so that their horoscopes must be the same.

See also  Truth Tables and Venn Diagrams: Prove Contingent statement are consistent

What attracted Augustine to Manichaeism?

Augustine explains his attraction to Manichean doctrine in terms of misplaced literalism — based on a literal reading of the Bible, the Manicheans accused Catholic Christianity of absurdity and immorality.

What does and does not Augustine find in the books of the Platonists?

What does Augustine NOT find in the books of the platonists? He does not find the Word of God in the books.

What is Augustine’s view on reality?

The statement is, Augustine tells us, perfectly true. He is saying that, as the eternal being of God stands to the world of change and becom- ing, so the vision of the truth stands to faith in temporal events. Though the vision of the eternal truth is the goal, the way to the truth is faith in the humanity of Christ.

Which is the soul’s tool to achieve wisdom and perfection?


And although a close relationship exists between our souls and our bodies, they are radically different entities. Our souls strive for wisdom and perfection, and reason is the soul’s tool to achieve this exalted state.